« 'Macroeconomics and the Centrist Dodge' | Main | Links for 07-01-2012 »

Saturday, June 30, 2012

'Giving Health Care a Chance to Evolve'

Robert Frank discusses market failures in health insurance markets, and how the president's health care plan helps to overcome them:

Giving Health Care a Chance to Evolve, by Robert Frank, Commentary, NY Times: ...Nearly every economic analysis of the health care industry rests on the observation that individually purchased private insurance is not a viable business model...
The fundamental problem is that ... people ... with serious pre-existing conditions ... are likely to need expensive care. Any company that issued policies to such people at affordable rates would be driven into bankruptcy, its most profitable customers lured away by competitors offering lower rates made possible by selling only to healthy people.
Economists call this the adverse-selection problem. Because of it, unregulated private markets for individual insurance cannot accommodate the least healthy — those who most desperately need health insurance.
Many countries solve this problem by having the government provide health insurance for all. In some, like Britain, the government employs the care providers. Others, like France, reimburse private practitioners — as does the Medicare program for older Americans. ...
Modeled after proposals advanced by the Heritage Foundation, the American Enterprise Institute and other conservative research organizations in the 1990s, the main provisions of the president’s health care law were intended to eliminate the most salient problems associated with the current system. ...
It isn’t that people should buy health insurance because it would be good for them. Rather, failure to do so would cause significant harm to others. Society will always step in to provide care — though in much more costly and often delayed and ineffective forms — to the uninsured who fall ill. To claim the right not to buy health insurance is thus to assert a right to impose enormous costs on others. Many legal scholars insist that the Constitution guarantees no such right. ...
What’s important now is how ... the law will ... extend coverage to tens of millions who now lack it. In addition, new insurance exchanges will provide a broader array of care options. ... The point worth celebrating is that last week’s ruling will at last enable our distinctly dysfunctional health care system to evolve into something better.

[More on market failures in health insurance markets here and here.]

    Posted by on Saturday, June 30, 2012 at 02:34 PM in Economics, Health Care, Market Failure, Politics | Permalink  Comments (129)

          


    Comments

    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.