« Paul Krugman: Delusions of Failure | Main | 'Keystone: The Pipeline to Disaster' »

Monday, February 03, 2014

'Silicon Valley Billionaires Believe in the Free Market, as Long as They Benefit'

Dean Baker:

Silicon Valley billionaires believe in the free market, as long as they benefit, by Dean Baker, theguardian.com: Last week, Mark Ames published an article ... on a court case that alleges that Apple, Google, and other Silicon Valley powerhouses actively conspired to keep their workers' wages down. According to documents filed in the case, these companies agreed not to compete for each others' workers dating at least as far back as 2005. ... This means not only that they broke the law, and that they acted to undermine the market, but that they really don't think about the market the way libertarians claim to think about the market. ...

The classic libertarian view of the market is that we have a huge number of people in the market actively competing..., there is so much competition that no individual or company can really hope to have much impact on market outcomes.

This point is central to their argument that the government should not interfere with corporate practices. For example, if we think our local cable company is charging too much..., our libertarian friends will insist that the phone company, satellite television or other competitors will step in to keep prices in line. They would tell the same story if the issue were regulating the airlines, banks, health insurance, or any other sector where there is reason to believe that competition might be limited. ...

The ... Silicon Valley non-compete agreements show that this is not how the tech billionaires believe the market really works. This is just a story they peddle to children and gullible reporters. ... The fact the Silicon Valley honchos took the time to negotiate and presumably enforce these non-compete agreements was because they did not think that there were enough competitors to hire away their workers. They believed that they had enough weight on the buy-side of the market for software engineers ... to ... keep their wages down. ...

    Posted by on Monday, February 3, 2014 at 09:36 AM in Economics, Market Failure, Regulation | Permalink  Comments (22)

          


    Comments

    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.