« Pin the Party Tale on the CEO (and it Won't Help to Wear the Armor...) | Main | Risks from a Slowdown in Housing »

Monday, January 02, 2006

Paul Krugman: No Bubble Trouble?

Paul Krugman says there is a housing bubble, a big worrisome bubble located in the Northeast Corridor, coastal Florida, much of the West Coast, and a few other locations:

No Bubble Trouble?, by Paul Krugman, Commentary, NY Times: In spite of record home prices, housing in most of America remains surprisingly affordable, thanks to low interest rates. That fact may seem to say that there's no housing bubble. But it doesn't. To see why, we need to brush up on our economic geography and economic history.

Let's start with the good news. A report in last week's Times ... found that for the nation as a whole, the cost of owning the median home is still only 23.7 percent of median family income, ... well below the peak of more than 30 percent reached in the early 1980's.

Now for the economic geography. Last summer I suggested that when discussing housing, we should think of America as two countries, Flatland and the Zoned Zone. In Flatland, there's plenty of room to build houses, so house prices mainly reflect the cost of construction. As a result, Flatland is pretty much immune to housing bubbles. ...

In the Zoned Zone, by contrast, buildable lots are scarce, and house prices mainly reflect the price of these lots rather than the cost of construction. As a result, house prices ... are much less tied down by economic fundamentals... By my rough estimate, slightly under 30 percent of Americans live in the Zoned Zone, which comprises most of the Northeast Corridor, coastal Florida, much of the West Coast and a few other locations. So ... results on affordability aren't surprising: most families live in Flatland, and haven't seen a big rise in the cost of home ownership.

But because Zoned Zone homes are much more expensive than Flatland homes, ... [b]y my estimate, more than half of the total market value of homes in the United States lies in the Zoned Zone. And ... the Zoned Zone accounts for the great bulk of the surge in housing market value over the last five years. So if we want to ask whether housing values make sense... [w]e need to focus on houses in the Zoned Zone. And there the numbers are anything but reassuring.

In the Zoned Zone, ... prices have risen so much that housing has become much less affordable. ... Even so, the current cost of owning a home in the Zoned Zone isn't entirely unprecedented. Roughly similar percentages of median family income were needed to afford houses in the early 1980's.

But that's hardly a comforting comparison, which is where the economic history comes in. You see, the unaffordability of housing in the early 1980's led to an epic collapse in the housing industry. ... And ... was one of the main factors in the worst economic slump since the Great Depression, which brought the unemployment rate to a peak of 10.8 percent at the end of 1982.

It's also worth noting that the reason housing was so expensive in 1981 and 1982 was that mortgage interest rates were extremely high. That made recovery easy, because all it took to make housing affordable again was for interest rates to return to normal levels. This time, with interest rates already low by historical standards, restoring affordability will require a big fall in housing prices.

So here's the bottom line: yes, northern Virginia, there is a housing bubble. ... Part of the rise in housing values since 2000 was justified given the fall in interest rates, but at this point the overall market value of housing has lost touch with economic reality. And there's a nasty correction ahead.

Post briefly discussing NY Times Housing story with link to Times story.

Previous (12/30) column: Paul Krugman: Heck of a Job, Bushie
Next (1/15) column: Paul Krugman: First, Do More Harm

    Posted by on Monday, January 2, 2006 at 12:15 AM in Economics, Housing | Permalink  TrackBack (2)  Comments (24)


    TrackBack URL for this entry:

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Paul Krugman: No Bubble Trouble?:

    » The Housing Babble from Wikistan

    Paul Krugman, when sticking to Econ 101, can actually be a reasonable read. ... [Read More]

    Tracked on Monday, January 02, 2006 at 01:09 PM

    » Mark Thoma talks housing from Altos Research Real Estate Insights

    Mark Thoma has a number of excellent posts over the last few days discussing general economic impacts of a bubble burst. Thoma takes a pragmatic view of the broader impacts of a bubble burst. The main risk arises when people start losing jobs in a [Read More]

    Tracked on Tuesday, January 03, 2006 at 05:01 PM


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.