« Brad DeLong: Insuring Against the Rising Tide of Global Risk | Main | The White House "Fact Sheet" on Veterans' Health Care »

Monday, March 05, 2007

Paul Krugman: Valor and Squalor

Paul Krugman looks at the reasons for the breakdown in veterans' care at Walter Reed Army Medical Center:

Valor and Squalor, by Paul Krugman, Commentary, NY Times [Update: complete article here.]: When Salon, the online magazine, reported on mistreatment of veterans at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center two years ago, officials simply denied that there were any problems. And they initially tried to brush off last month’s exposé in The Washington Post.

But this time ... the whitewash didn’t stick. ...

For all its cries of “support the troops,” the Bush administration has treated veterans’ medical care the same way it treats everything else: nickel-and-diming the needy, protecting the incompetent and privatizing everything it can.

What makes this a particular shame is that in the Clinton years, veterans’ health care — like the Federal Emergency Management Agency — became a shining example of how good leadership can revitalize a troubled government program. By the early years of this decade the Veterans Health Administration was, by many measures, providing the highest-quality health care in America...

But as with FEMA, the Bush administration has done all it can to undermine that achievement. And the Walter Reed scandal is another Hurricane Katrina: the moment when the administration’s misgovernment became obvious to everyone.

The problem starts with money. ... The quagmire in Iraq has vastly increased the demands on the Veterans Administration, yet since 2001 federal outlays for veterans’ medical care have actually lagged behind overall national health spending.

To save money, the administration has been charging veterans for many formerly free services. ... More important, the administration has broken longstanding promises of lifetime health care to those who defend our nation. Two months before the invasion of Iraq the V.H.A., which previously offered care to all veterans, introduced severe new restrictions.... [V]eterans whose income exceeds as little as $27,790 a year, and who lack “special eligibilities such as a compensable service connected condition...,” will be turned away.

So when you hear stories of veterans who spend months or years fighting to get the care they deserve, trying to prove that their injuries are service-related, remember...: all this red tape was created not by the inherent inefficiency of government..., but by the Bush administration’s penny-pinching.

But money is only part of the problem.

We know ... that one of the factors degrading FEMA’s effectiveness was the Bush administration’s relentless push to ... privatize disaster management, which demoralized ... and drove away many of the agency’s most experienced professionals. It appears that the same thing has been happening to veterans’ care.

The redoubtable Henry Waxman, chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, points out that IAP Worldwide Services, a company run by two former Halliburton executives, received a large contract to run Walter Reed under suspicious circumstances: the Army reversed the results of an audit concluding that government employees could do the job more cheaply.

And Mr. Waxman ... appears to have solid evidence, including an internal Walter Reed memo..., that the prospect of privatization led to a FEMA-type exodus of skilled personnel.

What comes next? Francis J. Harvey, who as far as I can tell was the first defense contractor appointed secretary of the Army, has been forced out. But the parallels between what happened at Walter Reed and what happened to New Orleans — not to mention parallels with the mother of all scandals, the failed reconstruction of Iraq — tell us that the roots of the scandal run far deeper than the actions of a few bad men.

Previous (3/2) column: Paul Krugman: The Big Meltdown
Next (3/9) column: Paul Krugman: Department of Injustice

    Posted by on Monday, March 5, 2007 at 12:15 AM in Economics, Health Care, Politics | Permalink  TrackBack (0)  Comments (108)


    TrackBack URL for this entry:

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Paul Krugman: Valor and Squalor:


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.