« Keeping the Public Fully and Honestly Informed | Main | The Economist: "It Seems That Those Whom the Gods Wish to Punish They First Make Neocons" »

Friday, April 20, 2007

Paul Krugman: The Plot Against Medicare

Paul Krugman says the plot against Medicare is moving forward, aided and abetted by some surprising allies:

The Plot Against Medicare, by Paul Krugman, Commentary, NY Times: The plot against Social Security failed: President Bush’s attempt to privatize the system crashed and burned when the public realized what he was up to. But the plot against Medicare is faring better: the stealth privatization embedded in the Medicare Modernization Act, which Congress literally passed in the dead of night back in 2003, is proceeding apace.

Worse yet, the forces behind privatization not only continue to have the G.O.P. in their pocket, but they have also been finding useful idiots within the newly powerful Democratic coalition. ... There’s no nice way to say it: the NAACP and the League of United Latin American Citizens have become patsies for the insurance industry.

To appreciate what’s going on, you need to know what has been happening to Medicare... The 2003 Medicare legislation created Part D, the drug benefit for seniors... Medicare, Part D isn’t provided directly by the government..., you can get it only through a private ... insurance company. At the same time, the bill sharply increased payments to Medicare Advantage plans, which also funnel Medicare funds through insurance companies.

As a result, Medicare — originally a system in which the government paid people’s medical bills — is becoming, instead, a system in which the government pays the insurance industry to provide coverage. And a lot of the money never makes it to the people Medicare is supposed to help.

In the case of the drug benefit, the private drug plans add an extra, costly layer of bureaucracy. Worse..., they have much less ability to bargain for lower drug prices than government programs like Medicaid and the Veterans Health Administration. ...

Meanwhile, those Medicare Advantage plans cost taxpayers 12 percent more per recipient than standard Medicare. In the next five years that subsidy will cost more than ... it would cost to provide all children ... with health insurance. ...

With the Democratic victory..., you might have expected these things to change. But the political news over the last few days has been grim.

First, the Senate failed to end debate on a bill — in effect, killing it — that would have allowed Medicare to negotiate over drug prices. ...[I]n spite of overwhelming public support..., 42 senators, all Republicans, voted no...

If we can’t even establish the principle of negotiation, a true repair of the damage done in 2003 ... seems politically far out of reach.

At the same time, attempts to rein in those Medicare Advantage payments seem to be running aground. Everyone knew that reducing payments would be politically tough. What comes as a bitter surprise is the fact that minority advocacy groups are now part of the problem, with both the NAACP and the League of United Latin American Citizens sending letters to Congressional leaders opposing plans to scale back the subsidy.

What seems to have happened is that both groups have been taken in by insurance industry disinformation, which falsely claims that minorities benefit disproportionately from this subsidy. It’s a claim that has been thoroughly debunked...— but apparently the truth isn’t getting through.

Public opinion is strongly in favor of universal health care, and for good reason: fear of losing health insurance has become a constant anxiety of the middle class. Yet even as we talk about guaranteeing insurance to all, privatization is undermining Medicare — and people who should know better are aiding and abetting the process.

Previous (4/16) column: Paul Krugman: Way Off base
Next (4/23) column: Paul Krugman: A Hostage Situation

    Posted by on Friday, April 20, 2007 at 12:15 AM in Economics, Health Care, Politics | Permalink  TrackBack (1)  Comments (67)


    TrackBack URL for this entry:

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Paul Krugman: The Plot Against Medicare:

    » Krugman’s Dark Conspiracies from Health Care BS

    Paul Krugman, via Economist’s View, is sounding more and more like Colonel Jack D. Ripper when discussing health care. Whereas Colonel Ripper was fearful that dark forces were undermining his precious bodily fluids, Krugman’s bêtes noire are appar... [Read More]

    Tracked on Friday, April 20, 2007 at 07:31 PM


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.