« links for 2007-10-19 | Main | Paul Krugman: Death of the Machine »

Friday, October 19, 2007

"Libertarians Rising"

Michael Kinsley says computers turn people into libertarians:

Libertarians Rising, by Michael Kinsley, Time: To oversimplify: Democrats are for Big Government; Republicans are against it.

To oversimplify somewhat less, Democrats aren't always for Big Government, and Republicans aren't always against it. Democrats treasure civil liberties, whereas Republicans are more tolerant of government censorship to protect children from pornography, or of wiretapping to catch a criminal, or of torture in the war against terrorism. War in general and Iraq in particular--certainly Big Government exercises--are projects Republicans tend to be more enthusiastic about. Likewise the criminal process: Republicans tend to want to make more things illegal and to send more people to jail for longer. Republicans also consider themselves more concerned about the moral tone of the country, and they are more disposed toward using the government in trying to improve it. In particular, Republicans think religion needs more help ... through the government, while Democrats are touchier about the separation of church and state.

Many people feel that neither party offers a coherent set of principles... For them, the choice is whether you believe in Big Government or you don't. And if you don't, you call yourself a libertarian. Libertarians are against government in all its manifestations. ... And what is the opposite of libertarianism? Libertarians would say fascism. But in the American political context, it is something infinitely milder that calls itself communitarianism. The term is not as familiar, ... in general communitarians emphasize society rather than the individual and believe that group responsibilities (to family, community, nation, the globe) should trump individual rights.

The relationship of these two ways of thinking to the two established parties is peculiar. Republicans are far more likely to identify themselves as libertarians... And yet Republicans have a clearer vision of what constitutes a good society and a well-run planet and are quicker to try to impose this vision on the rest of us. Now that the Republican Party is in trouble, critics are advising it to free itself of the religious right on issues like abortion and gay rights. That is, the party should become less communitarian and more libertarian. With Democrats, it's the other way around.

Very few Democrats self-identify as libertarians, but they are in fact much more likely to have a live-and-let-live attitude toward the lesbian couple next door or the Islamofascist dictator halfway around the world. And every time the Democrats lose an election, critics scold that they must put less emphasis on the ... rights of individuals and more emphasis on responsibilities to society. That is, they should become less libertarian and more communitarian. ...

The ... party that does well in the future will be the one that makes the better guess about where to place its bets. My money's on the libertarians. ... The computer revolution has bred a generation of smart loners, many of them rich and some of them complacently Darwinian, convinced that they don't need society--nor should anyone else. They are going to be an increasingly powerful force in politics.

He says "Republicans have a clearer vision of what constitutes a good society and a well-run planet..." They do?

    Posted by on Friday, October 19, 2007 at 12:24 AM in Economics, Politics | Permalink  TrackBack (0)  Comments (131)

    TrackBack

    TrackBack URL for this entry:
    https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b33869e200e54f0ed9288834

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Libertarians Rising":


    Comments

    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.