« "Against Gender based Taxation" | Main | links for 2008-02-09 »

Saturday, February 09, 2008

Did the World Bank's Development Efforts Fail in Kenya?

What does Kenya tell us about economic and social development?:

Did Development Fail in Kenya?, by Jean-Michel Severino, Project Syndicate: A month ago, Kenya fell prey to a sudden burst of post-electoral violence... The intensity and scale of the violence have stunned the world. ...

[T]hings seemed to be going well recently. This year's campaign was exceptionally peaceful... Perhaps more fundamentally, Kenya was unanimously seen as the "good student" of development, sometimes referred to as a symbol of an African renaissance.

The "Kenya vision 2030 framework," a set of ambitious macroeconomic, legal, and constitutional reforms, was being implemented in close partnership with the World Bank. Cherished by the donor community, Kenya received almost $1 billion of official development assistance in 2006 - up by 250% since 2002. Its booming horticulture and tourist industries were hailed as models for other African states...

The country's economic expansion, which averaged 5.5% in the last four years and fuelled the progress of neighbouring economies, appeared to prove that vigorous growth is possible in Africa even without mineral or fossil resources. Today, this economic miracle is up in the air. All is not lost, and there are strong reasons to believe that Kenyans will ... put the country back on its promising track.

Nevertheless, as we sit on the brink of the abyss, it is worth re-examining our assumptions that since poverty breeds conflict, socio-economic development must foster political stability and reduce recourse to violence.

The first lesson we should draw from this month of civil strife is that development, however well-managed, cannot solve everything. Some tensions are deeply ingrained in societies, and peace requires more than any development agency can deliver. Parallel to the growth agenda, there is a specific role for bilateral and multilateral diplomacy to play in support of improved governance.

In fact, development itself generates a number of strains on societies that lie at the very roots of conflict. Fast-paced changes of identity caused by urbanisation, the empowerment of women or exposure to foreign media tend to weaken traditional norms and social networks...

By displacing traditional centres of power, development can nurture collective resentment. Ethnic manipulation is a small step away, which many political leaders are disposed to take. None of this, however, disproves the link between development and peace, or inverts the correlation.

At both the micro and the macro level, development projects and economic growth can do much to alleviate some of the structural causes of political violence. But development professionals, ... should be more conscious of the complex strains brought upon developing societies. ...

Ultimately, the enhanced economic activity that development generates is the only way to reduce inequalities... Moreover, fast-paced but ill-distributed economic growth can be accompanied by programmes that focus on those who are left behind, thereby mitigating grievances.

It is no coincidence that much of Kenya's ongoing violence is occurring in the slums of its large cities. Had more attention been given to the country's most glaring inequalities in access to water, shelter, or jobs, this population might not have chosen violence as an instrument of change.

Let us draw the right lessons from Kenya: socio-economic progress remains our best tool to prevent conflict in the long run. But the relationship between growth and political stability is subtler and less linear than we like to believe.

Development is no miracle solution to violence, and may create its own set of grievances - particularly when done without regard to the abrupt changes it brings to societies.

Kenya isn't an illustration of development failing, but of development at work: complex, powerful, and yet fragile. [Jean-Michel Severino is former World Bank vice president]

    Posted by on Saturday, February 9, 2008 at 12:03 AM in Development, Economics | Permalink  TrackBack (1)  Comments (55)


    TrackBack URL for this entry:

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Did the World Bank's Development Efforts Fail in Kenya?:

    » Prosperity and Violence from Prose Before Hos

    [During the Cold War,] aggressively championing plans for rapid economic development, political elites in the developing world used their control over the economy to organize the polity, distributing patronage in order to stay in power Th... [Read More]

    Tracked on Wednesday, February 13, 2008 at 09:50 AM


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.