« links for 2008-06-24 | Main | More Speculation »

Tuesday, June 24, 2008

Sovereign Debt Risk

Something else to worry about?:

Watch Out for Sovereign Debt Risk, by Carmen M. Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, Commentary, WSJ: Optimists say that emerging-market defaults are a thing of the past. Emerging markets today, the argument goes, are relying more on domestically issued local currency debt, both inflation-indexed and non-indexed. This means their debts are far more stable and reliable than in the recent past, when a much larger share of government debt was issued externally and denominated in hard currency.

This argument is wrong. In the past, the combination of high levels of domestic debt and inflation surges has often proven deadly for both foreign and domestic investors. Just look at Argentina today...

Already, a good share of Argentina's debt is in default. What else do you call it when a government that owes over $30 billion in inflation-indexed debt ... is publishing an understated inflation rate that is used for calculating indexation payments. The official inflation rate in Argentina ... is under 10%. But the true inflation rate appears to be at least 30%... Fudging indexation clauses to effectively default on debt is an old game. ...

Over the course of history, emerging-market economies have had a hard time shaking off serial default. Each period of quiescence has been invariably followed by more turmoil, with the share of total countries in the world in default sometimes exceeding 40%, as it did during the mid-19th and 20th centuries.

Considering the duress of domestic bond holders across the world as global inflation rises, it is surprising that both private investors and multilateral international financial institutions seem so complacent about the rising risks of defaults on external debts.

The "this time is different" mentality is based on two mistakes. The first is the idea that domestic debt is something new. The other is the faulty economic logic that payments to domestic debt holders come out of a different pot than payments to external debt holders. ...

Earlier eras offer scant evidence that external creditors have been much safer than domestic debt holders. When India effectively defaulted on its domestic debt through massive inflation and financial repression in the early 1970s, external debt holdings suffered payment reschedulings even though they constituted only a tiny fraction of overall debt.

Emerging markets could be in much greater trouble than the optimistic consensus suggests. If today's tepid growth in the U.S., Japan and Europe begins to take hold in emerging markets, Argentina's miserable indexed bond holders may soon have company.

    Posted by on Tuesday, June 24, 2008 at 12:24 AM in Economics, International Finance | Permalink  TrackBack (0)  Comments (10)


    TrackBack URL for this entry:

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Sovereign Debt Risk :


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.