« links for 2009-02-21 | Main | Should the EU Let a Member Government Default? »

Saturday, February 21, 2009

"How to Lift a Falling Economy"

Ricardo Caballero proposes that the government guarantee the future price of bank shares as a means of halting "the deadly spiral of fear and panic":

How to Lift a Falling Economy, by Ricardo J. Caballero, Commentary, Washington Post: ...Since Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner's recent announcements, shares of the main U.S. financial institutions have imploded yet again. The Dow Jones industrial average keeps falling. And to make matters worse, politics has decidedly entered into the process of economic policymaking... Talk of nationalizations has become widespread, as if government takeovers were a panacea, further reinforcing the deadly spiral of fear and panic. ...

Here is a proposal: The government pledges to buy up to twice the number of bank shares currently available, at twice some recent average price, in five years.

While the policy is about future (and unlikely) interventions, the immediate impact would be enormous. In particular, it would turn around the negative dynamics of stock markets, and it would allow banks to raise private capital.

The most direct effect would be an increase in the price of banks' shares, as the pledge puts a floor on the price, but the upside potential is huge once we get over the hurdle posed by this crisis. That is, buying equity from these banks would become like buying Treasury bonds plus a call option on the upside. By the strong forces of contagion, this rise would immediately spread to non-financial shares. Consumers, especially retirees, would see some of their wealth replenished; insurance companies' balance sheets would improve; destabilizing short sellers and predators would be wiped out (as happened in Hong Kong in 1997); and we would have the foundations for a virtuous cycle.

The second, and reinforcing, effect would be the stabilization of the financial sector, as banks would possess the conditions necessary to raise private capital. Until now, banks have not wanted to raise capital because it would be highly dilutive at current prices. Potential investors have no interest in injecting capital because there is an enormous fear of further dilutions, especially through public interventions or, worse, outright nationalizations. A pledge to support the shares would reverse these dynamics and quickly recapitalize the banking sector.

How much would this cost taxpayers? Probably nothing. It is unlikely that the crisis will last five years... If the market prices surpass the government-pledged sale prices, there would be no cost to taxpayers. There ... is no real reason not to try such a proposal...

Update:See the comments by James Kwak.

    Posted by on Saturday, February 21, 2009 at 12:24 AM in Economics, Financial System | Permalink  TrackBack (0)  Comments (61)


    TrackBack URL for this entry:

    Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "How to Lift a Falling Economy":


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.