« Fed Watch: The Output Gap Debate Continues | Main | Federal Rulemaking During This Administration »

Monday, March 19, 2012

Paul Krugman: Hurray for Health Reform

Will health care reform survive its dishonest opponents?

Hurray for Health Reform, by Paul Krugman, Commentary, NY Times: It’s said that you can judge a man by the quality of his enemies. If the same principle applies to legislation, the Affordable Care Act — which ... for the most part has yet to take effect — sits in a place of high honor.
Now ... ObamaRomneycare ... isn’t easy to love, since it’s very much a compromise... Can such a system work? It’s already working! Massachusetts enacted a very similar reform ... while Mitt Romney was governor. Jonathan Gruber ... has surveyed the results — and finds that Romneycare is working pretty much as advertised. The number of people without insurance has dropped sharply, the quality of care hasn’t suffered, and the program’s cost has been very close to initial projections. ...
Given this evidence, what’s a virulent opponent of reform to do? The answer is, make stuff up.
We all know how the act’s proposal that Medicare evaluate medical procedures for effectiveness became, in the fevered imagination of the right, an evil plan to create death panels. And rest assured, this lie will be back in force once the general election campaign is in full swing.
For now, however, most of the disinformation involves claims about costs. Each new report from the Congressional Budget Office is touted as proof that the true cost of Obamacare is exploding, even when ... the document says on its very first page that projected costs have actually fallen slightly. Nor are we talking about random pundits making these false claims. We are, instead, talking about people like the chairman of the House Republican Policy Committee, who issued a completely fraudulent press release after the latest budget office report.
Because the truth does not, sad to say, always prevail, there is a real chance that these lies will succeed in killing health reform before it really gets started. And that would be an immense tragedy for America...
As I said, the reform is mainly aimed at Americans who fall through the cracks in our current system — an important goal... But what makes reform truly urgent is the fact that the cracks are rapidly getting wider, because fewer and fewer jobs come with health benefits; employment-based coverage actually declined even during the “Bush boom” of 2003 to 2007, and has plunged since.
What this means is that the Affordable Care Act is the only thing protecting us from an imminent surge in the number of Americans who can’t afford essential care. So this reform had better survive — because if it doesn’t, many Americans who need health care won’t.

    Posted by on Monday, March 19, 2012 at 12:34 AM in Economics, Health Care, Politics | Permalink  Comments (66)


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.