« Have Blog, Will Travel: Dallas Fed Housing, Stability, and the Macroeconomy Conference | Main | 'The Backbones of Banana Slugs' »

Thursday, November 14, 2013

'What are Some of the Biggest Problems with a Guaranteed Annual Income?'

Busy with the conference, so I'll toss this out to you: any comments on this post from Tyler Cowen?:

What are some of the biggest problems with a guaranteed annual income?: Maybe this isn’t the biggest problem, but it’s been my worry as of late.  Must a guaranteed income truly be unconditional?  Might there be circumstances when we would want to pay some individuals more than others?  Many critics for instance worry that a guaranteed income would excessively reduce the incentive to work.  So it might be proposed that the payment be somewhat higher if low income individuals go get a job.  That also will make the system more financially sustainable.  But wait — that’s the Earned Income Tax Credit, albeit with modifications.
Might we also wish to pay more to some individuals with disabilities, perhaps say to help them afford expensive wheelchairs?  Maybe so.  But wait — that’s called disability insurance (modified, again) and it is run through the Social Security Administration.
As long as we are moving toward more cash transfers, why don’t we substitute cash transfers for some or all of Medicare and Medicaid health insurance coverage benefits, especially for lower-value ailments?  But then we are paying more cash to the sick individuals.  That doesn’t have to be a mistake, but it does mean that an initially simple, “dogmatic” payment scheme now has multiplied into a rather complex form of social welfare assistance, contingent on just about every relevant factor one might care to cite.
You can see the issue. ...[continue]...

    Posted by on Thursday, November 14, 2013 at 09:03 AM in Economics, Social Insurance | Permalink  Comments (60)


    Comments

    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.