« 'Job Growth Remains Strong in February' | Main | How Inequality Harms Health -- and the Economy »

Friday, March 06, 2015

Paul Krugman: Pepperoni Turns Partisan

Why are Republicans in the grips of "Big Pizza"?:

Pepperoni Turns Partisan, by Paul Krugman, Commentary, NY Times: If you want to know what a political party really stands for, follow the money. ... Major donors ... generally have a very good idea of what they are buying, so tracking their spending tells you a lot.
So what do contributions in the last election cycle say? The Democrats are, not too surprisingly, the party of Big Labor (or what’s left of it) and Big Law: unions and lawyers are the most pro-Democratic major interest groups. Republicans are the party of Big Energy and Big Food: they dominate contributions from extractive industries and agribusiness. And they are, in particular, the party of Big Pizza.
No, really. ... And pizza partisanship tells you a lot about what is happening to American politics as a whole. ...
The rhetoric of this fight is familiar. The pizza lobby portrays itself as the defender of personal choice and personal responsibility. It’s up to the consumer, so the argument goes, to decide what he or she wants to eat, and we don’t need a nanny state telling us what to do. ...
But..., anyone who has struggled with weight issues ... knows that this is a domain where the easy rhetoric of “free to choose” rings hollow. Even if you know very well that you will soon regret that extra slice, it’s extremely hard to act on that knowledge. Nutrition, where increased choice can be a bad thing,... it ... is one of those areas — like smoking — where there’s a lot to be said for a nanny state.
Oh, and diet isn’t purely a personal choice, either; obesity imposes large costs on the economy as a whole.
But you shouldn’t expect such arguments to gain much traction. For one thing, free-market fundamentalists don’t want to hear about qualifications to their doctrine..., and partisan orientation: heavier states tend to vote Republican...
At a still deeper level, health experts may say that we need to change how we eat, pointing to scientific evidence, but the Republican base doesn’t much like experts, science, or evidence. Debates about nutrition policy bring out a kind of venomous anger ... that is all too familiar if you’ve been following the debate over climate change.
Pizza partisanship, then, sounds like a joke, but it isn’t. It is, instead, a case study in the toxic mix of big money, blind ideology, and popular prejudices that is making America ever less governable.

    Posted by on Friday, March 6, 2015 at 09:58 AM Permalink  Comments (23)


    Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.